Life of Pie

I made two pie crusts this weekend. Not just regular crusts, either—I made the worst pie crusts in the history of pastry. The phrase “I’ve had worse,” would have been a compliment.

In my defense, I’d never made crusts before. But even that doesn’t explain the sheer awfulness of what I created. My crusts were so thick and tough that they could not be cut or chewed without effort. They were so sturdy, they functioned as disposable plates. I’m not convinced that they were actually compostable.

Somehow, by blending flour, sugar, salt, butter and water, I’d managed to create a material that could be used to strengthen plaster, plug up leaks in a foundation or fill potholes.

To add insult to injury, one of the pies was also undercooked, so it had no redeeming qualities whatsoever. Since I hate wasting food, I gave that pie to a friend—a friend who refuses to admit that anything might be inedible. This is a guy who believes expiry dates are dares…a guy who believes a 26-year-old can of peas is still “just fine”…a guy who once made—and somehow managed to eat—beef ribs that he’d pan-fried for just five minutes. We haven’t heard from him since he drove off with the pie. I fear my crust may have killed him.

After everyone else left, I found the Martha Stewart baking show I’d taped several weeks ago…and then forgotten to watch. Martha carefully explained the 10 essential steps for a perfect pie crust. Turns out I botched a few of the steps—10 of them, to be precise.

So I’m borrowing my oldest daughter’s food processor, I’ve printed out Martha’s recipe and I’m trying again. This weekend we’re having chocolate cream pie. Or we’re having chocolate pudding on a disposable crust plate. I’ll let you know how it goes.

6 thoughts on “Life of Pie

  1. Martha Orlando

    Lol, Brenda! Pie crust is NOT an easy endeavor by any means. I’ve tried my share, and now it’s Pillsbury crusts with my own imaginative fillings. Forget the rolling pin and the “don’t touch the dough too much.” Over it!
    Hoping you have better luck the next time!

    1. Brenda Post author

      Fingers crossed! I figured if I tried the chocolate cream version, next, at least I could scrape out the filling and eat THAT if the crust is still plate-like 🙂

  2. Arnold Forsyth

    Brenda: Your Dad would have eaten the pie! You should have called us Brenda. Carole made five pies for Thanksgiving and we had two left over. Sorry but they are gone now. Carole and I enjoy “A” slice of pie only on special occasions but the other members of our Family request pecan, 2 apple and 2 pumpkin so you could have had your pick. We will remember that for another time.
    You will do a good job on the pie for this weekend, I know.

    1. Brenda Post author

      My dad was there, actually – he wisely chose to eat the watermelon and left the pie alone, LOL! Thank you for your kind words. Sounds like I should have come to YOUR place on Sunday – Mrs. Forsyth is an amazing cook. I still remember her rice pudding – yum! 🙂

  3. Dad

    I didn’t have any problem at all with the pie crusts!!!
    I found it very easy to eat the red stuff in the watermelon and leave the “crust” behind.
    The rest of the meal was delicious … forget about the pie, bring on the watermelon.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *